Foreign Policy Magazine
New Volcom Stone Otto Premium Circle Snapback Hat Cap Black Gray White SkatePeligroSports Snapback Yupoong Mexico Shield Hat,JAMAICA Embroidered Baseball Hat Palm Tree Surf Classics Strapback Cap c3,USS JOHN F. KENNEDY ENLISTED RANK INSIGNIA EMB CAP HAT,PRE-OWNED ADULT TITLEIST ACUSHNET CANADA VINTAGE GREY VISOR STITCHED,LIFE IS GOOD SOCCER PLAYER yellow adjustable cap / hat - 100% cotton,VTG-1982 Campbell's Beananza Soup veggies retro supreme snapback hat sku12,Green Bay PACKERS Heather Hype Snapback,Addict X DC Comics Official Adults Unisex Superman Beanie NS4298,HARD ROCK ROCKSINO NORTHFIELD PARK ADJUSTABLE HAT/CAP CASINO GAMBLING NEW NWT,Orange Crush HAT - Distressed Orange Corduroy W/ Orange/White Patch - Fitted M/L,Hat Cap Dodge Viper Red Line H195,ROUTE 66 HIGHWAY MAP LOS ANGELES TO CHICAGO BASEBALL CAP HAT BEIGE,BILTMORE HEMP TWO TONE WHITE/GOLD FEDORA DRESS HAT SIZE 7 1/8,Oaklawn Horse Racing Gaming AR Yellow Mesh Trucker Baseball Hat Cap Adjustable,Double S Hat collection comfort size 7 cowboy western Ivory - Hand Woven,Metal Mulisha Realtree adjustable trucker men hat,OKLAHOMA CITY THUNDER OKC NBA ADIDAS NAVY BEANIE,WOOL BLEND TWEED HERRINGBONE NEWSBOY GATSBY CAP GOLF DRIVING IVY HAT GREY GRAY,2018 NWOT NEFF DAILY SNAPBACK CAP black red white casual hat,Polo Ralph Lauren Cuff Hat Cap Beanie Wool/Nylon NWT Polo Black,Vintage Green Myrtle Beach Palm Trees Souvenir Snapback Trucker Hat Cap,DISSE OUTDOOR GEAR HAT CONCEALED CARRY PRODUCTS GREEN/BEIGE ADJUSTABLE VGC C20,DC SHOES WONDER 210 FLEXFIT MEN'S BROWN & TAN HAT CAP S/M NEW,KITH NEW ERA NY YANKEES CLASSIC FITTED CAP HAT 59FIFTY SIZE 7 1/8 - 7 3/4,Red INVICTA RUSSIAN DIVER Watch Hat Baseball Cap Raised StitchingNWT WOMENS KB ETHOS CADET/MILITARY STYLE HAT BROWN SIZE MEDIUM K,NHL MINNESOTA WILD PINK FRONT-WILD SYMBOL BACK SLIDING ADJUST NEW WITH TAGS,SunBody Hats Palm Leaves Wide Brim Western Sumbraro M 7 3/8 59,Hat Cap Ford Camo Camouflage Mesh Back H227,Vintage Miami Dolphins Football Snapback Trucker Hat Cap Team NFL LOGO 7,NASA Logo Embroidered Baseball Cap Snapback Patched Mesh Back Trucker Hat Black,Kith X Coca Cola Womens Checkered Crop Tee,TaylorMade TM 83 Classic Golf Hat Cap B12001 Black/Burgundy Throwback New,University of Texas Longhorns Gameday Authentic Hat - Fitted M/L,

Faux Leather Hip-hop Sun Outdoor Fishing Beach Bucket Boonie Cap Hat Women Men,


The only remaining question is what exactly he's guilty of.

U.S. President Donald Trump speaks to members of the media on former national security adviser Michael Flynn's lying to the FBI prior to his Marine One departure from the South Lawn of the White House Dec. 4, in Washington, D.C. (Alex Wong/Getty Images)

By now, any sentient being who is capable of rational thought about the U.S. president (a category that admittedly excludes his more fervent fans) must grasp the likelihood that there was a quid pro quo between the Trump campaign and the Kremlin: Russian President Vladimir Putin would help Donald Trump win the U.S. presidential election, and in return Trump would lift sanctions on Russia.

The fact that Trump hasn't made good on his end of the presumed bargain shouldn't be any surprise: A long line of business partners and wives have discovered how worthless his commitments are. In fairness, however, Trump's failure to follow through in this instance wasn't necessarily because he didn't want to; it was because the Russian meddling became public and therefore made it politically impossible for Trump to help out his Russian pal even if he had been inclined do so.

Trump's failure to deliver doesn't change the probability that this corrupt bargain existed. No other hypothesis can account for the copious links that have emerged between the Trump campaign and the Russians. As CNN notes, "At least 12 Trump associates had contacts with Russians during the campaign or transition. There were at least 19 face-to-face interactions with Russians or Kremlin-linked figures. There were at least 51 communications - meetings, phone calls, email exchanges and more."


If the Trumpites and the Putinites weren't communicating about how to subvert Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton's campaign, what were they talking about? Their favorite brands of vodka? And if there was an innocent explanation for all of these contacts, why is it that everyone in the Trump campaign, from the president on down, has lied and lied and lied about them? Those are the damning questions that no Trump defender can answer.

Trump personally has issued at least nine blanket denials of any connections to Russia (Trump in February: "I have nothing to do with Russia. To the best of my knowledge no person that I deal with does.") even as evidence of those connections has accumulated like debt on Trump casino projects. His associates including Attorney General Jeff Sessions, Vice President Mike Pence, crown prince Jared Kushner, and first son Donald Trump Jr. have been equally vociferous - and duplicitous - in their denials.

Two Trumpites - former foreign-policy advisor George Papadopoulos and former national security advisor Michael Flynn - have now pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI about their Russia ties. After Flynn entered his guilty plea last week, Trump tweeted: "It is a shame because his actions during the transition were lawful. There was nothing to hide!" So if there was nothing to hide, why did Flynn commit a felony? Is he a compulsive liar who can't stop himself from dissembling even when it would be more advantageous to tell the truth?

The Occam's razor explanation for why Flynn lied is that the truth was so terrible that it was worth risking jail time to conceal it. It seems improbable that he was lying merely to hide a violation of the Logan Act, although it is undeniable that the Trump campaign did violate this statute, which prohibits unauthorized persons from negotiating with foreign governments "in relation to any disputes or controversies with the United States."

Flynn was clearly engaged in negotiations with then-Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak while Barack Obama was still president. He was urging Russia to stop the passage of a United Nations Security Council resolution censuring Israel and, more significantly, not to retaliate for the sanctions that Obama imposed to punish Russia for its interference in the U.S. presidential campaign to benefit Trump. But no one has ever been convicted of a violation of the Logan Act, and Flynn would have to be extraordinarily dense to lie to the FBI to avoid a Logan Act offense. The more likely explanation is that Flynn's contacts with Kislyak were part of a pattern of covert negotiations between the Trump campaign and the Kremlin. Now there's an offense that would be worth hiding from the FBI.

The question is no longer whether there was collusion between the Kremlin and the Trump campaign. Clearly there was. That became undeniable this year when we learned that Don Jr.'s reaction to an overture from a Kremlin emissary offering dirt on Clinton was "I love it." Further evidence has since emerged that both Don Jr. and the head of the campaign's data analytics firm, Cambridge Analytica, communicated secretly with WikiLeaks, the conduit for emails stolen by Putin's intelligence services. Trump, for his part, practically advertised the collusion during the campaign by repeatedly praising Putin and defending him from charges of hacking into Democrats' accounts even while publicly asking him to release Clinton's emails.

The question is whether Trump's collusion was limited to the public realm or was there a secret dimension to it? Was he aware of, and did he approve, the Kremlin contacts pursued by his underlings? In other words: What did the president know, and when did he know it?

There is circumstantial evidence that Trump was well aware of what his aides were up to. Flynn was no lone operator: Kushner, identified in the plea document as a "very senior member of the Presidential Transition Team," was directing his outreach. Also closely involved was Flynn's deputy, K.T. McFarland, while she was with Trump himself at Mar-a-Lago. And as soon as Putin accepted Flynn's entreaty not to retaliate for Obama's sanctions, Trump took to Twitter to praise Putin's "very smart" move. It beggars belief that Trump was unaware of the Flynn-Kislyak contacts while they were occurring in December 2016 - just as it beggars belief that he was unaware of the meeting that his entire campaign high command had in June 2016 with Kremlin emissary Natalia Veselnitskaya.


The issue is what special counsel Robert Mueller will be able to prove. Given that Flynn is now a cooperating witness, who must have given up a lot of valuable information to get such a lenient plea deal, the special counsel is most likely assembling a strong case. Like any other prosecutor unraveling a complex criminal conspiracy, he is working his way up the food chain - and with the former national security advisor in his grasp, there aren't many targets left who are more senior. You're talking Pence, Sessions, Trump Jr., Kushner - and of course Trump himself.

It's possible, even probable, that, unlike Flynn, the other officials won't flip because they will be confident that Trump will pardon them. That's especially likely in the case of Trump's son and son-in-law. But this would be a corrupt use of the pardon power that could itself be an article of impeachment against the president - and likely will be if the Democrats win the House next year.

Already the evidence of Trump's obstruction of justice - the same offense that brought down Richard Nixon - is compelling, which is why a White House lawyer is advancing the novel argument that the president can't be guilty of obstruction. The president has publicly admitted that he fired FBI Director James Comey because of "this Russia thing." Following the Flynn plea deal, Trump tweeted: "I had to fire General Flynn because he lied to the Vice President and the FBI." If Trump knew at the time that Flynn had lied to the FBI, that strengthens the case that he was obstructing justice when he asked Comey to pledge his personal loyalty and to give Flynn a break ("I hope you can let this go").

Once White House aides figured out that Trump's tweet had increased his legal jeopardy, they trotted out one of the president's lawyers, John Dowd, to take the fall for the offending comment. Even if Dowd put the incriminating words in his client's mouth, this might well be a Freudian slip that reveals the truth that the White House is so anxious to conceal. The same might be said about a recently reported email that McFarland sent on Dec. 29, 2016: "If there is a tit-for-tat escalation Trump will have difficulty improving relations with Russia, which has just thrown U.S.A. election to him," she wrote. This may or may not have been an admission of guilt on her part (the context is ambiguous) - but it was at least an admission that this was how his election looked and for good reason. That impression has only grown stronger in the past year.

A recent Washington Post article on the Mueller team ended with a revealing vignette: "People familiar with the Mueller team said they convey a sense of calm that is unsettling. 'These guys are confident, impressive, pretty friendly - joking a little, even,' one lawyer said. When prosecutors strike that kind of tone, he said, defense lawyers tend to think: 'Uh oh, my guy is in a heap of trouble.'" Contrast the special counsel's calmness with the flop-sweat evident on Trump's Twitter account: He is desperately trying to distract attention from his own worsening legal situation by impugning "Crooked Hillary" and even the FBI. Naturally, he shows no awareness of how unseemly it is to trash a defeated political opponent or the very law enforcement officers he is sworn to lead.

The contrast is telling, and, for Trump's dwindling band of defenders, it should be deeply discomfiting: the confident prosecutors, building their case piece by piece against the panicked president lashing out at all directions because he is terrified that he will be found guilty of colluding with a hostile foreign power to undermine American democracy.

Item specifics

New with tags: A brand-new, unused, and unworn item (including handmade items) in the original packaging (such as
Size: XS, S, M, L, XL, 2XL
Style: Australian Cowboy/Western Material: Leather
Main Colour: Black Brand:

Rixom Leather

Features: Waterproof, Wide Brim Theme: Australian

About the Author

Max Boot is the Jeane J. Kirkpatrick senior fellow for national security studies at the Council on Foreign Relations. His forthcoming book is "The Road Not Taken: Edward Lansdale and the American Tragedy in Vietnam." @MaxBoot

Max Boot is the Jeane J. Kirkpatrick senior fellow for national security studies at the Council on Foreign Relations. His forthcoming book is "The Road Not Taken: Edward Lansdale and the American Tragedy in Vietnam." @MaxBoot
Vintage New York Yankees 1998 World Series Champions Hat 90s MLBAdjustable Black Polo Ralph Lauren Hat,STROKA LAND Country Club Golf White Hat Sportsman Great Name Witty,New Era Flagship Collection Nyc Brand New 59fifty 7 1/2,KOOKAI - Gorgeous Women’s Chocolate Colour Crop Jacket size 36,Era NHL Chicago Blackhawks Biggest Fan Redux Beanie,Milwaukee Bucks Fear The Deer 9FORTY Adjustable Cap,Fox Racing Murc Toner Snapback Hat - Adult Mens Guys Lid Cap MX ATV MTB,New Era 39Thirty Stretch Fit Buffalo Bills Blue Cap,Volcom Quarter Twill Mens Headwear Cap - Navy One Size,US Woodland Camo BDU CAP All Sizes American Army Field Hat Ripstop Camouflage,BRIXTON MACH HP SNAPBACK SKATE SHOP FREE POSTAGE AUSTRALIAN SELLER KINGPIN,Milwaukee Bucks NEW ERA 59FIFTY Fitted Hat NBA East Conference Throwback Size 7,CHEVY Trucks Racing 1990's Camoflauge Racing Snapback Hat Adjustable NWT's WOW,NewNBA Sacramento Kings Flatbill Fitted Hat - 3D Embroidered Cap - O S F A,47 BRAND TEAM NBA ORLANDO MAGIC MARZ MENS SPORT SNAPBACK HAT 7434302617612,Vtg DIXIE DAIRIES OLD TIMERS Prichard AL Snapback Trucker Hat Baseball Ball Cap,1955 Disneyland Mesh Material Baseball Hat Cap and Adjustable Strap NWT NOS,Gibbs Trucking Black Baseball Cap Snap Back,Horror Punk Misfits Rock Trucker Snap back Baseball Fiend Cap Double Side Black,Real Madrid Football Club Official Purple Knitted Beanie Hat Crest RMCFBrand New Mitchell & Ness Brooklyn Nets SnapBack Hat One Size Fits All [VR04Z],New Stetson Camouflage Hat RealTree No Fly Zone Camo Baseball Cap Adjustable NWT,Unisex Mens Womens Casual Cotton Greek Fisherman Cap Sailor Seaman Mariner Hats,Fox Face Cute Animal Embroidered 2 Tone Bobble Pom Pom Beanie Hat Logo Womens,A Kurtz Men's 7 Flex Baseball Cap,RANGERS FC CAP HAT SOCCER/FOOTBALL SCOTLAND SCOTTISH RAMPANT LION ST ANDREW'S,Mitchell & Ness Chicago Bulls Black Snapback Hat Hologram symbol under Visor Cap,Rolling Stones Men's Trucker Hat Trucker Cap Adjustable Black,New Era Leaders Chicago 1354 Brand New Unworn 9fifty SnapBack,
THE OLYMPIC CLUB orange adjustable visor - slightly distressed,

Welcome back

Sign in to your Foreign Policy account

Need an account?

Sign up for free access to 3 articles per month and weekly email updates from expert policy analysts

Sign Up

Already have an account? Log in

Sign Up

Create a Foreign Policy account to access 3 articles per month and free newsletters developed by policy experts

Want unlimited access? Subscribe today.

Go Back
  • Under Armor Beanie Hat Skull Cap Soft Fleece Reversible
  • Supreme Independent Old English 5-Panel Hat Cap FW17 Navy Black with a pin
  • University of Texas Longhorns Gameday Authentic Hat - Fitted M/L
  • Masters 2008 OFFICIAL Golf Hat Adjustable Green American Needle 100% Cotton
  • Matching Mitchell &Ness New York Islander snapback for Jordan 4 retro Dunk above
  • Vans x Spitfire Shallow Unstructured Dress Blues White Hat
  • Spiderman New Era Cap Hat Fitted 7 1/4 Panel Sub Dual Logo DC Comics 59Fifty